Responses to Five Great Waves-- Movements since 1960

 

 

The AJ Thomas said...

First off I just want to say thanks for mentioning the Reformed Baptists. We appreciate it. I see two possibilities. Small Groups / Community, or this whole emergent thing. i think the emergent thing is more likely to own the 2010-2020 decade though.

Sunday, January 29, 2006 9:04:30 PM

 

 

JohnLDrury said...

Could it be Cross-cultural and even multi-lingual ministry?

This is where the major growth in many denominations is happening, and they are getting on board. The local church without a Spanish-speaking service or at least a recently daughtered one is the "cutting edge".

maybe ....

Sunday, January 29, 2006 11:32:48 PM

 

Diane Muir said...

Well, that certainly flooded me with memories! I grew up as a UMC pastor's kid and experienced ALL of those things. And I had never really separated them into these categories, but you are right on. The 70s were filled with Jesus people and Lay Witness Missions. We had huge Holy Spirit Conferences and everyone was doing all they could to introduce Jesus to the world. Evangelism Explosion was HUGE! And those teachings have stuck with me for years. And then, I grew up - spent the early 80s in a local church where all I heard was church growth. And I REMEMBER the concerns that Billy Graham was creating half-baked Christians. Oh ... what did we know? Such amazing cycles of Christian outreach we have faced in these short years.

What's to come? People are desperate to move back into intimacy with each other and with their Creator. The computer has created an interesting world for us. We have more information about everything ... than ever before. And we move at a faster pace daily. Our churches will become havens. A safe place from the world of insanity where we can communicate with each other. These may be in house churches, or small groups / communities or small, satellite communities off a large mega-church. I think we will return to neighborhood (defined however you'd like to define that) groups where people care for each other.

There is already a push to be more like the New Testament churches and as the world separates us from each other, the church will bring us back together.

In smaller communities - where there are no mega-churches, they will still be experiencing the worship boom of the 90s for quite some time. They are already masters of community life. This is what the mega-church groups will try to emulate.

This is fun to consider! I'm looking forward to what you think! And 2026? Oh, I can't wait to look back to this age and see it as history.

Monday, January 30, 2006 12:10:13 AM

 

Andrew Overby said...

My guess is that cultural relevance will be the next wave. We see this already with sermon series designed around major movies. We already hear terms like "redeem the culture." Instead of attepmpting to create an alternative Christian culture we will be trying to be Christians in our culture.

Monday, January 30, 2006 12:44:41 PM

 

Anonymous said...

This has been a trip down memory lane. Just think of all the money that's been made on each of these concepts! I don't know of one concept that's been as divisive as the so-called "worship wars." How sad to tell the 60-somethings..if it's too loud you're too old...get with the program or find another church where you'll be more comfortable. Where's the spirit of Christ in that statement?

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 6:32:55 AM

 

Anonymous said...

Great article, Keith. I admire the way you can take a topic and melt it down to managable, concise points, easy to remember. Reminds me of "Strategetics!"

All the above comments are great. I think perhaps we will see this decade as one focused on "Freedom in the Spirit." In trying to synthesize all this history, we will take an "anything goes" stand. We will stay united doctrinally, but in teh practical outplay we will be open to whatever the Spirit brings.

Tim Hawk

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 8:19:43 AM

 

Nathan Crawford said...

I'd say that there may be two movements that may vie for the spot. I'd say that one would be the Rick Warren movement, with its purpose driven stuff and all that goes along with it. The other may be the emergent church, or at the least, the reclaiming of some sort of tradition. Although, I still think those emergents are reclaiming tradition so as to be efficient at getting people to get in and stay in the church, which falls under the Rick Warren model. So maybe, it's just Rick Warren.

My hope though is that it may be the melding of faith and action in trying to do more than get people in the church by allowing the church to go out and meet people in their settings and ways. Maybe I'd like to call this a social justice decade. Won't happen, but it's my hope.

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 12:42:52 PM

 

 

Scott said...

This generation will see a renewal of apostolic ministry (aka the Ephesians 4 fivefold ministry team of apostle, prophet, evangelist, pastor and teacher) leading regional networks of simple/organic/house churches.

I believe we will eventually see house churches in every neighborhood, making the Church more easily accessible. These churches are easily reproducible and will fare equally well in both urban and rural settings.

Two great resources are Neil Cole's book "Organic Church" and Wolfgang Simson's book "Houses That Change the World." I highly recommend both of them.

Scott Estep

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 2:49:02 PM

 

MattH said...

I am not sure where the church is headed but here are my thoughts about what could happen. I believe that singing and praise will be a major part of worship but hopefully it will not overtake the preaching of the word like it has in the last 10 years. I agree with John that more multicultural settings will start to pop up especially in the urban areas. I can see more demand being for a bi-lingual pastor instead of a pastor who can sing or play the piano. Women will play a much more leading role in the church than they are today, we are already seeing 2 or 3 women preachers on the television where 10 years ago you saw zero. I think as land aquisition gets hard and more expensive to do that churches will begin to look at supporting a daughter church in the same town instead of buying a 50 acre plot and building a million dollar facility. I also think that more churches will get involved with private schools because of the frustration over the public school cituation. Oh and Jesus will return on July 12, 2009;) J/K but I am sure there will still be those who will try to set the date and more writings like the Da Vinci Code will be in print.

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 3:37:59 PM

 

Kris Heiple said...

nifty thoughts.

not to sound pessmistic, but if the world makes it to the next generation--i believe the evangelical emergents will own the next wave.

sending all the baggage and "forms of godliness but not tapping into the power of God" to the fire and coming out with a purer universal church.

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 9:56:28 PM

 

Erskine said...

What a thought-provoking question! I've come up with several ideas in the last several minutes and, being impulsive, I'm going to post them and then think about it. :)

One possibility is "reality." Many Christians talk lately about being "real," "relavant," and "deep." It seems to me that many emergent churches are linked with this at some level.

Another possibility, in my mind, is a crisis over "call." It's such an archaic term and a sacred cow in my small area of the world. People just don't understand the word as much anymore; they understand the principle. Then there are denominations like ours that push the call so that we fill our denominational colleges and universities and wind up scaring students away with an archaic term.

I also think this decade is ushering in a season of persecution unlike any we've seen before. It's not here yet, but I think it's inevitable with the Religious Right controlling a large segment of world power. People will inevitably link Christianity with Religious Right politicking, and anti-Religious Rightists will become anti-Christians. (I hope I'm not too far afield with that. I'm not generally a dooms-dayer.)

By the way, when did IWU begin offering worship ministry as a major? I was under the impression that a student there would have to double-major in Christian ministry and music to come close to that.

If anyone has read this far, you should really read Dr. Drury's book "The Wonder of Worship." It's in my top 25 non-fiction books. It's in my top 3 worship books. (There's a lot of rubbish out there.)

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 9:59:04 PM

 

me again ^ said...

i forgot to mention the increase in discilpleship..a keen observation i've made is--evangelism is all the craze, but where does that get new Christians besides "sneaking" into heaven? I've got a bad feeling that a sad portion of church's aren't feeding us. i'd like to see more teaching and less decieving.

again, i don't mean to come off anti-church, or pessimistic, but i can't let my concerns go unsaid.

-A son in Christ

Tuesday, January 31, 2006 10:01:28 PM

 

James Petticrew said...

I think this decade will be the decade of theology when the pragmatism of the church growth movement will be replaced by the work of a new generation of pastor theologians. These practical theologians will work the opposite way from the church growth movement, they will start with God and work out ecclesiology and missiology in the light of that theology.

Wednesday, February 01, 2006 1:53:11 AM

 

 

Rev. C. S. Roberts said...

It may be known as the age of "rethinking the church." That could be good and bad. If all we do is think and not act then we have failed and this decade will be remembered as a failed attempt to do something great... and the Osteenesque crap will carry on and grow and a generation will be lost.

Or the age of rethinking could be followed by the age of "recreating the church." This is my hope and perhaps our only hope if we plan on reaching out to anyone under the age of 35 today.

Wednesday, February 01, 2006 10:08:57 AM

 

Thinking in Ohio said...

Here's hoping:
The emergent movement... their theology is liberal, their hold on scripture sinks into the mud (not a high and lofty stand), and their moral standards are weak... but maybe, just MAYBE... they will leave a positive mark on this decade.

I believe their greatest contribution is their apolgetics and push for cultural relevance... in the emergent movt. the unchurched find a "meeting place" where they can come in contact with Christ without fear of intimidation or rejection. The emergents are "gentle and respectful" (see 1 Peter) in their evangelistic agenda and the unchurched find that attractive. Maybe they'll teach conservative evangelicals that we can win back the culture without declaring war on "liberals" and "sinners"?

Wednesday, February 01, 2006 11:10:38 AM

 

Dean said...

I'm leaning toward a split between purpose driven and emerging from what I can tell. The two seem to have competing structural views, so it's hard to see them uniting. One also seems to come more from the Reformed side (take a guess which) and the other from Arminian Pietistic streams.

Wednesday, February 01, 2006 6:09:48 PM

Delete

 

Larry said...

I must be getting old--I remember them all ;-)

IMHO, the next "movement" will be toward community. Each of the previous decades was about getting bigger. The next one will be about getting smaller.

Wednesday, February 01, 2006 9:16:25 PM

 

JustKara said...

I think it will be intimacy --small groups of caring friends...even large churches will have to deconstruct their (our!) (my!) approch to mega-religion, mega-worship, and mega-everything else. -JustKara

Thursday, February 02, 2006 11:25:06 AM

 

 

Keith.Drury said...

Good ideas so far... here's a summary of your nominations for how this current decade might be labeled in the future--as to what God brought back into His church during these 10 years:

Apologetics
Apostolic ministry & simple/organic/house churches
Cross-cultural and even multi-lingual ministry?
Intimacy, relationships, church-as-haven
Cultural relevance
Discipleship
Emergents
Freedom in the Spirit
Persecution
Reality
Rethinking the church
Rick Warren movement
Small Groups / Community, or this whole emergent thing.

Social justice
Theology—especially ecclesiology

So what do YOU think? Additions? You support one of these?

--Keith Drury

Thursday, February 02, 2006 11:44:10 AM

 

Kurt A Beard said...

I'll go for individualist church movement. By that I mean Churches do what works best for them movement or the non-carbon copy movement. No more identical churches but churches that are locally stylized.
I'll call it the local dive movement as opposed to the national chain movement.

Thursday, February 02, 2006 6:22:32 PM

 

John Mark said...

One possible trend that has not been mentioned is the interfaith trend that has been produced by a number of factors, the so called culture wars, the New Age movement, etc. Does anyone think this is creeping into the church? My guess is that some denominations are vulnerable to this, when they have rejected orthodoxy. Maybe this is not "big enough" to count as a trend, at least not yet.

Friday, February 03, 2006 3:14:11 PM

 

Anonymous said...

Two thoughts come to mind when I think of how we will think of this decade. One would be the decade of church planting. There has been a push in many denominations to plant new churches.

The other is "the Purpose Driven Era". The popularity of the books and the way they have been used throughout the church world brings this issue to the forefront. I realize that it is a rehashing of the last three waves, but it still has had an impact on the church nonetheless.

Friday, February 03, 2006 10:55:52 PM

 

Tom Bird said...

It seems to me I am seeing a greater and greater emphasis on authenticity and mission mindedness; one leads to the other. It appears that a lot of leaders are trying to bring us out of the so-called church growth and worship eras into a soul searching time, when we are trying to get our hearts right before the Lord. It seems that if all the people brought in during the growth and worship phases would now turn their hearts and minds toward what God wants done in the world, we would see a tremendous growth for the kingdom.

Saturday, February 04, 2006 8:39:10 AM

 

bumble said...

I love the way you see one wave led to another in the past. And follow that trajectory, I guess the next wave would be community.

There's a need to build community to deepen the mega-churches (Community, not neighborliness).

On the social/cultural side, the gen-M is much more communal than Gen-Xers and Boomers. Community would be the draw of the church there.

And mega-church can certainly crossbreed with emergents too (Rob Bell's church is huge, and Bill Hybel's church could be communal too)

Well, but what do I know. I am still haven't figure out how to even grow myself yet...

Sunday, February 05, 2006 12:53:30 AM

Keith.Drury Winds Up With...

 

Thanks for your thoughtful responses and ideas.  My hunch is we never know in the decade what will be its contribution until the following decade, but there definitely are hints, aren’t there. I find that I’m tempted to mix my own opinions with my predictions. So I’ll just admit that and do it: I’m hoping that this will turn out to be a decade of “spiritual formation” or “relationships” and it will restore to the church an approach to “church” that brings the next great wave—becoming a “means of grace” to the world… but, like I admitted, I’m probably mixing my dreams and desires with my predictions. My son Dave posted his opinions posing as a writer from 2046.

 

Thanks again for your thoughtful and helpful responses….    --Keith

Respond here to this week's column.

"Five Great Waves--movements since 1960"
http://www.drurywriting.com/keith/five.great.waves.htm

What do YOU think will become the current "wave?"



(Please use the other post below for all other columns and other comments or questions.)

.