Why Should Protestants Care
By David
Drury
Whenever a Pope vacates
Saint Peter’s throne and heads to heaven to bow before The Throne ancient bureaucratic
wheels in the
But why should we
Protestants care?
Here’s why:
The S
For many Protestants the
most monumental contribution of Pope John Paul II and the Catholic Church of
late is in the battle over abortion.
There has been great unity among the Evangelical Movement and the
Catholic Church over this issue: forging unique and tight bonds in the Pro-Life
movement. In fact, the position of the
Catholic Church on abortion has been far more stalwart than the evangelical
church at large (and some would say it has much more philosophical and medical
integrity). For this reason, Protestants
should care who the next Pope is and pray for the Cardinals to have discernment
and wisdom in their choice. Frequently
Popes are elected to overcompensate for the weaknesses of their predecessor,
and to perhaps deemphasize any overemphasis as well. While the Catholic church seems quite unified
on this issue, it is not set in stone that the next Holy Father will speak so
unequivocally on the Sanctity of Life regarding abortion (or in matters of
assisted suicide, capital punishment and reproductive technology). The next Pope may simply provide less leadership
here and more in other matters.
The c
The small “c” here in
catholicity is used to denote the “entire unified church” around the globe,
which includes us. Perhaps no person
embodies a hope for worldwide unity of the church more than the Pope. Since the Reformation there are massive
ecclesial and governmental divisions to this catholicity, but the ecumenical movement, more recently the emergent in the
Response to Ministeri
The scandal of Priests
abusing children has rocked the reputation of the Catholic Church in many
places, perhaps most notably in the Eastern United States and in Ireland. But it has also cast a pall over ministers
everywhere, in a much more visceral and criminal way than the financial
scandals of the 80s Televangelists have.
The response from the next Pope to the existing and any future
scandals—and possible reforms in the accountability, structure and style of
Priesthood—will affect Protestants as well.
Women in the Ministry
The issue of women becoming
priests has been largely sidelined as improbable and out of the mainstream in
the Catholic Church. However, there is a
large underground movement within Catholicism to push this issue with the next
Papal regime. The forced celibacy of
priests is a related issue here, and the scandals have gone so far as to
re-raise this potential within Catholicism.
Protestants as a whole are going in opposite directions on this issue,
and both “sides” will be wise to care about any potential shifts within the
Catholic priesthood policy. For my part,
I do hope to see this equality established in the Catholic Church as it is in
my own Wesleyan Church. However, I think
we both should refrain from ordaining Snead O'Connor.
Theologic
The theological power of the
Pope is nearly infallible within the Catholic Church. This, of course, is part of our major
“protest” against Roman Papalism as Protestants. However, that theological power has bled into
many other denominations and movements in history, even since the
Reformation. We have largely focused on
the political statements of the Pope in the past century. We should be ready for theological statements
of the Pope in the coming one.
Politic
But the political force of
the Pope is huge. When John F Kennedy
was elected president many wondered if “the White House would take its cues
from the Vatican.” This worry was somewhat
unfounded, but rooted in a sense that the political positions of the Pope have
a great bearing on governments everywhere.
Perhaps this is the most lasting legacy of Pope John Paul II, who spoke
to political issues with frequency and effectiveness. The Evangelical Right has nothing on the Pope
when it comes to political power.
Spiritu
The entire spiritual dynamic
of the Church worldwide is affected by the Pope. John Paul II was extremely effective at
elevating his office to the place of “world spokesman for religion” and
therefore we should care about this election for that reason alone if no others. Whether we like it or not, the Pope speaks
for us from time to time. If not in the
current day, then at least in history he speaks for us. Perhaps I’m overestimating the direction the
Pope gives to the spiritual climate and dynamic of all churches and their
influence on the culture around them.
But as Pope John Paul II is memorialized and some other cardinal must
fill the massive white shoes of this Polish Pope, we will be reminded of the
huge role he played on the international stage in the past quarter-century.
Perhaps Protestants underestimate
how much can float away on the smoke rising from the Vatican chapel chimney.
© 2005 by David Drury
ß Reponses now
closed
Back to the
Writer’s Attic